Create Account

Username
Password
Remember me
Email
 
0

Really, We Have Gotten To This??

13 comments, 207 views, posted 4:19 am 23/05/2012 in Religion by Viscera
Viscera has 11856 posts, 1476 threads, 1078 points, location: 1123 6536 5321
Lord of Glencoe

H.S. senior's diploma withheld after graduation Tebow-ing

Tim Tebow hopes his prayerful football pose helps spread a positive message regardless of how it's interpreted.

But not everyone's on board.

CAPTIONBy Kirby Lee, US Presswire

Bishop Verot Catholic High School (Fort Myers, Fla.) senior Chuck Shriner Tebow-ed on stage Saturday prior to receiving his graduation diploma ... however his principal, with the full backing of Shriner's mother, withheld the sheepskin as punishment.

"I just thought it was fun," Shriner tells WPTV-NBC. "I was just doing it to make graduation memorable."

Mission accomplished, Chuck.

Students and parents apparently burst into laughter as Shriner took a knee and bowed his head as Tebow has done for the past seven years on the gridiron dating to his own Florida high school days. Shriner won a $5 bet for doing it, though contends the money wasn't a factor.

His mother, a math teacher at the school who was angered by her son's actions, picked up his diploma Monday -- but only after he'd cleaned up the gymnasium where the graduation was held.

"They said what I did would give underclassmen inspiration to do something else, that it might lead to something else," Shriner said. "So they were trying to set an example."

But he doesn't seem to have any regrets.

"She was really mad," Shriner said. "But I think it was worth it."


article here

Comments

2
4:20 am 23/05/2012

Viscera

in a Catholic high school, now it's inappropriate to kneel in apparent prayerful posture? I am so sick of PC bullsh*t

1
4:27 am 23/05/2012

z0phi3l

Catholics are a unique breed of oxymorons

2
5:44 am 23/05/2012

backroom

Quote:
Really, We Have Gotten To This??


To what?
To where a principle and a mother are demonized for instilling a bit of discipline?
or
To where this story recieves any attention at all?

0
7:31 am 23/05/2012

grnday3415

At least it wasn't Faith Hill-ing.

2
12:07 pm 23/05/2012

elsels

People have lost all common sense, they want to make everyone a criminal, or just like a criminal. They want to make examples out of each person even when it doesn't apply. Whatever, poor kids of today, I do feel horrible for them because as much as we have "progressed" the brain has yet to catch up to all that progress, so what we have are people that are all too pc and don't want to offend anyone, or want to be dictators in the classroom or in school or in the office. No wonder kids are really fu**ed up nowadays, can't say I blame them.

On graduation day, we did all kinds of stupid crap, we had a guy in our class come with only his undershorts (nothing exposed of course), tennis, cap and gown of course he flashed the crowd. It was funny, we laughed, the principal laughed and gave him his diploma simple was the name back then. It has been 22 years today since I graduated from high school, if we were graduating today he would be arrested and we would all be expelled. We would need to walk in single file, quietly and act like robots or risk insulting, offending, upsetting, aggravating some school dictator or worst.

We also had an invocation (a prayer) at the ceremony and those who did not want to participate and we were many did not.

0
5:23 am 24/05/2012

Viscera

Quote by backroom:
Quote:
Really, We Have Gotten To This??

To what?
To where a principle and a mother are demonized for instilling a bit of discipline?
or
To where this story recieves any attention at all?


no, that a kid at a Catholic HS can't kneel down in an apparent prayerful posture at a graduation without getting shit from people. I graduated from a Catholic HS, and the nuns would have given thanks if someone did that. People bitch about the idea that God and religion don't belong in public school but now the act is being removed from a private Catholic one as well

2
10:54 am 24/05/2012

Edorph

Gotta say, I think you're over-analyzing this. It sounds like someone trying to be funny during the ceremony and being disciplined for it.
The silliness of the "OMG, PCness stole my lunch" crowd is starting to rival that of the PC crowd itself.

Partly related: isn't there something in the bible about how one should pray discreetly? What's your view on this Tebow-ing phenomenon?

0
2:42 pm 24/05/2012

Viscera

the command about opraying dsiscreetly was a direct contrast to hypocritical prayer, (the Pharisees were the example of what not to be) so I'm not against the act of public thanksgiving.

I might be misreading this, if the kid was being a smartass, then yes he should get into trouble, but my point is 2 fold. Being an athlete at a religious school, there is just as real a chance that he wasn't just acting up, and that maybe he admires Tebow and did it for that reason (It doesn't say why he was dared, maybe he does this when he plays, and the team mates knew it would be frowned upon, so they said to do it).

And 2, it isn't an unreasonable act of expression (certainly I have seen more inappropriate acts done at graduations), so why the furor from the school and his mother? There seems to be more to this story either way. It isn't the end f the world either way, just a pet peeve of mine personally

1
2:56 pm 24/05/2012

backroom

The "missing" link from your original article...
no, you did not intentionally leave it out...
Points to the story as presented by a local tv station.
VERY INTERESTING READ
Perhaps it will put the story in the proper perspective for you because...

Quote by Viscera:
I might be misreading this, if the kid was being a smartass, then yes he should get into trouble,


he was just being a smart ass and the "punishment" was his mothers idea.

0
3:01 pm 24/05/2012

Viscera

I knew it was his mothers idea, that was in the first article. I don't see anythjing different other then the $5 reference and he said he would have done it for free. But if he was being a smartass, then he deserved the punishment

3
3:01 pm 24/05/2012

z0phi3l

It was a fucking graduation, it's not like he ran in during mass and whipped his dick out or anything that required punishment, it was the young mans way of showing gratitude for finally finishing HS, we all felt it that day, some were just noticeably more outgoing about it

1
4:24 pm 24/05/2012

Edorph

Quote by z0phi3l:
.. ran in during mass and whipped his dick out ..


Coincidentally a staggeringly accurate description of ceremonial canon in my religion.
I agree it was a little weird/harsh to withhold his diploma because of it though, but perhaps not the "have we gotten to this!?"-moment that Viscera thought.

1
9:38 pm 24/05/2012

Quaektem

Quote by z0phi3l:
it was the young mans way of showing gratitude for finally finishing HS



.. or just being a smartass punk. Why does he care about the diploma anyway? I dropped mine in a box when I got home and haven't looked at it since.

Add Comment

Log in via teoti, or register to add a comment!