Create Account

Username
Password
Remember me
Email
 
74

LIfeguard and supporters fired for saving drowning man

11 comments, 230 views, posted 1:19 am 05/07/2012 in WTF! by HariSeldon
HariSeldon has 4264 posts, 2233 threads, 57 points
Uber God

Six Florida lifeguards have lost their jobs for backing a coworker's decision to save a man struggling in the surf but outside their jurisdiction.

Tomas Lopez , 21, was fired Monday for vacating his lifeguarding zone to save a man drowning in unprotected waters 1,500 feet south of his post on Hallandale Beach, Fla.

"I knew I broke the rules," said Lopez, who ran past the buoy marking the boundary of his patrol zone to help the man. "I told the manager, I'm fired aren't I?"

Lopez said he jumped into the water and "I double underhooked him…I was worried about the guy and his health. He was blue."

Six of Lopez's coworkers said they would have done the same thing. And now, they've been fired too.

"I can listen to the rule and tell them that I wouldn't help someone who was distressed, but I knew if the incident ever came up I would go," said 19-year-old Brian Ritchie, who was fired today for saying he too would rescue someone outside his patrol zone.

"What we're basically supposed to do is watch them die," said 16-year-old Zoard Janko, who also backed Lopez's decision.

A spokesman for Jeff Ellis and Associates, the aquatic safety contractor that fired Lopez, said in a statement that "We have liability issues and can't go out of the protected area."

"Usually when the municipalities hire someone to [lifeguard], those organizations are not only taking on the responsibility of the job, but a lot of the liability," said Tom Gill, a spokesman for the United States Lifesaving Association. But, he added, "It seems unfortunate that a guard would do what he's trained to do and be fired for it."

By the time Lopez arrived on the scene, other beachgoers had dragged the unconscious man ashore and started CPR. He is recovering at Aventura Hospital, according to the Sun Sentinel.

Lopez said he didn't think about the consequences of his instinctive run "until after it was said and done."

"[We] should have jurisdiction to help someone without worrying about losing our jobs," he said.

Don't give a damn about liability issues. If you are capable of saving a person's life. If your very job description is saving a person's live you don't give an excuse of "sorry that's not my table". This company should lose its contract. Reminds me of a story when firefighters and other rescue crew watched a man drown because they were ordered not to rescue the man since they didn't have proper training to save a man in 3' of water. At least here you had a human being willing to do the right thing.

Extra Points Given by:

golfhack (25), griffin (5), Flee (10), marksyzm (5), bradpitt (10), Quaektem (5), spykesmom (10)

Comments

5
1:27 am 05/07/2012

golfhack

Once again the world shows me what a shit-hole it is. The human race is nothing more than a virus on the planet.

5
1:27 am 05/07/2012

Flee

He should sue and win...
http://www.floridamalpractice.com/stat768.13.htm
Good Samaritan Act; immunity from civil liability.—
(1) This act shall be known and cited as the "Good Samaritan Act."
(2)(a) Any person, including those licensed to practice medicine, who gratuitously and in good faith renders emergency care or treatment either in direct response to emergency situations related to and arising out of a public health emergency declared pursuant to s. 381.00315, a state of emergency which has been declared pursuant to s. 252.36 or at the scene of an emergency outside of a hospital, doctor's office, or other place having proper medical equipment, without objection of the injured victim or victims thereof, shall not be held liable for any civil damages as a result of such care or treatment or as a result of any act or failure to act in providing or arranging further medical treatment where the person acts as an ordinary reasonably prudent person would have acted under the same or similar circumstances.

5
1:28 am 05/07/2012

griffin

Quote by HariSeldon:
A spokesman for Jeff Ellis and Associates, the aquatic safety contractor that fired Lopez, said in a statement that "We have liability issues and can't go out of the protected area."


Translation: our liability issues are more important than human life.

1
1:39 pm 05/07/2012

cyvoid

i thought there was a law making it illegal for those with the training to assist in a situation to not assist. ie a doctor can not legally walk away from a person in distress.

5
8:21 pm 05/07/2012

thecrookedman

Florida lifeguard says he's been offered his job back

More

2
8:30 pm 05/07/2012

bradpitt

Quote by thecrookedman:
Florida lifeguard says he's been offered his job back

More

the power of the media's great is'nt it

0
11:02 pm 05/07/2012

Sypher_5

The shit hole is the USA, please don't mistake the US's need to insure everything, sue over everything, and put a price value on everything is in anyway a reflection to the way the rest of the world works.

3
3:29 am 06/07/2012

HariSeldon

Quote by Sypher_5:
The shit hole is the USA, please don't mistake the US's need to insure everything, sue over everything, and put a price value on everything is in anyway a reflection to the way the rest of the world works.



The American said Fuck You and saved a life. The American co-workers all stuck up for him even at the cost of their jobs. The American people demanded and got his job back.

25 people in England sat and watched a man drown because they were told that it was 3' of water was too dangerous. Plus there have been several similar stories that happened in England

It's certainly not the first time this has happened. Last year, a 14-year old girl in London collapsed while in the middle of a cross-country competition. It took emergency workers 30-minutes to arrive, at which point they refused to carry her body through the muddy park to the ambulance as it was against health and safety regulations.

Then there was the case of 44-year old Alison Hume in Scotland; she had fallen into a mine shaft and was trapped there for six hours suffering from hypothermia because emergency service supervisors claimed that using their winch to retrieve her would be a violation of regulations.

10-year old Jordon Lyon of northern England, who was drowning in a local pond when two community support officers arrived to the scene... and did absolutely nothing because they weren't properly trained.

Sure those in charge defended their cold actions, actions which left people to drown. Sure they claimed it was for safety reasons. Even if we give them the benefit of the doubt, it is no less obscene to sit idle and watch a person drown for fear of being hurt.

The American "Shit hole" people understood that. No doubt the family members of the victims wish your people did.

1
7:09 am 06/07/2012

Sypher_5

I'm sorry I'm I don't live in UK either. Also, it was in response to Golfhacks comment suggesting that there not places in the world where people will get shit done regardless of the rules. While common sense is definitely not common, I'm not too sure anyone I knew would say "nope, sorry, I'm sorry there's a rule stopping me from being a human with a conscience.".

1
1:47 pm 06/07/2012

cyvoid


There aren't. there are isolated decent people, but the world is a shit hole. Pick your region pick your country there is something of a shit hole about it. be it basic lack of fresh water, child soldiers, stoning women, or an over obsession with liability.

0
9:48 pm 06/07/2012

marksyzm

Quote by HariSeldon:
The American "Shit hole" people understood that. No doubt the family members of the victims wish your people did.


Whoa... pretty harsh there, Hari - 4th July is over, buddy!

Add Comment

Log in via teoti, or register to add a comment!